Constitutional Law

The attorneys at Williams & FInkbine have proven success in the legal rules and principles that establish the structure of a government, define its powers, and protect the fundamental rights of individuals.

The Ohio Constitutional and Civil Rights Defense Attorneys at Williams & Finkbine represents governmental entities, public officials, employees, insurers, and other clients in civil litigation involving alleged violations of rights protected by the United States Constitution and federal law.

Constitutional litigation presents issues that differ significantly from traditional tort claims. Cases may involve the scope of a constitutional right, whether that right was clearly established at the time of the alleged conduct, the availability of qualified or other immunity, governmental liability under federal law, and the relationship between constitutional and state-law claims arising from the same events.

Our attorneys have experience defending constitutional claims in Ohio’s state and federal courts and handling related issues on appeal. We approach these matters with an emphasis on early identification of the controlling legal issues, development of the factual record, and evaluation of opportunities for dismissal or summary judgment when supported by the law and facts.

Statewide Constitutional and Civil Rights Defense

Williams & Finkbine represents governmental entities, public officials, employees, insurers, and other clients in constitutional and civil-rights litigation throughout Ohio.

With offices in Columbus, Cincinnati, and Cleveland, our attorneys handle matters in state and federal courts across Ohio and provide representation through trial and appellate proceedings.

Our constitutional litigation practice draws upon the firm’s broader experience in political subdivision liability, employment liability, insurance defense, federal court litigation, and appellate advocacy to address the overlapping legal issues these cases frequently present.

Discuss a Constitutional or Civil Rights Matter

Williams & Finkbine Co., L.L.C. represents governmental entities, public officials, employees, insurers, and other clients facing constitutional and federal civil-rights claims throughout Ohio.

To discuss a new matter, submit a case for consideration, or obtain assistance with constitutional issues arising in pending litigation, contact our civil litigation team.

Coverage Areas

Section 1983 and Constitutional Rights Litigation

Section 1983 and Constitutional Rights Litigation

Many civil constitutional claims against governmental entities and public officials are brought under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, which provides a civil remedy for certain violations of rights secured by the United States Constitution and federal law.

Williams & Finkbine defends public entities, officials, and employees against claims alleging constitutional violations arising from the performance of governmental functions.

These cases may present questions concerning whether a constitutional violation occurred, whether an individual defendant may assert qualified immunity, whether the allegedly violated right was clearly established, whether the governmental entity itself can be subject to liability, and whether the plaintiff can establish the causation and damages necessary to maintain the claim.

Because these issues can affect the scope and direction of the litigation at an early stage, we evaluate potential immunity and dispositive defenses promptly.

First Amendment Claims

Our attorneys defend claims arising under the First Amendment to the United States Constitution.

First Amendment litigation may involve allegations concerning freedom of speech, retaliation for protected expression, political affiliation or patronage, freedom of association, or other governmental action alleged to interfere with constitutionally protected activity.

These cases frequently require careful analysis of both the nature of the claimed constitutional right and the governmental interests implicated by the challenged conduct.

In employment-related matters involving public entities, First Amendment claims may also overlap with retaliation, discrimination, employment, and statutory claims. Our experience in both governmental liability and employment litigation allows us to address those related issues within a coordinated defense strategy.

Due Process & Equal Protection Claims

Williams & Finkbine defends governmental entities and public officials against claims arising under the Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment.

Due process claims may involve allegations concerning governmental procedures, protected property or liberty interests, employment decisions, enforcement actions, or other governmental conduct.

Equal protection claims may involve allegations that a governmental entity or official treated an individual or group differently in violation of constitutional protections.

Our attorneys evaluate the nature of the claimed constitutional interest, the governmental action at issue, the applicable standard of review, and the factual record necessary to defend the claim.

Claims Involving Law Enforcement, Detention, and Governmental Conduct

Constitutional claims may arise from the activities of law enforcement officers, correctional or detention personnel, governmental agencies, and other public employees performing official duties.

Depending upon the circumstances, these matters may involve alleged violations of the Fourth, Eighth, or Fourteenth Amendments and may be accompanied by state-law claims for negligence, intentional torts, wrongful death, or other alleged misconduct.

Williams & Finkbine's experience defending governmental entities and their employees allows us to evaluate the federal constitutional claims alongside related Ohio-law causes of action and available statutory or common-law immunities.

Qualified Immunity

Qualified immunity can be a significant issue in constitutional litigation involving individual public officials.

The defense generally requires analysis of both whether the alleged conduct violated a constitutional right and whether that right was clearly established under controlling law at the relevant time.

Because qualified immunity can provide protection from litigation itself rather than merely a defense to ultimate liability, the timing and procedural posture in which the issue is raised can be particularly important.

Our attorneys evaluate qualified immunity and other available defenses early in the litigation and develop the factual and legal record necessary to present those issues when appropriate.

Municipal & Governmental Liability

Claims against a governmental entity present issues distinct from claims against an individual public employee.

Under federal law, a municipality is not ordinarily liable under § 1983 simply because it employed an individual alleged to have violated someone's constitutional rights. Claims against municipalities may instead involve allegations concerning governmental policies, customs, practices, training, supervision, or decision-making.

Williams & Finkbine represents political subdivisions and other governmental entities facing these claims and evaluates both the alleged underlying constitutional violation and the separate requirements for imposing liability upon the governmental entity.

Constitutional claims may also be accompanied by causes of action arising under Ohio law. Our attorneys have experience addressing Ohio's political-subdivision immunity statutes and other defenses that may apply to related state-law claims.

Constitutional Claims in Public Employment

Constitutional litigation can also arise from the public employment relationship.

Government employees may assert claims involving freedom of speech, political affiliation, procedural or substantive due process, equal protection, and other constitutional protections, often together with claims under federal or Ohio employment statutes.

Williams & Finkbine's employment liability and governmental defense practices provide experience addressing these overlapping theories.

We work with public employers and their insurers to evaluate the challenged employment action, the governmental interests involved, applicable constitutional standards, available immunity defenses, and any related statutory employment claims.

Federal Court Litigation

Constitutional claims are frequently litigated in federal court.

Williams & Finkbine represents clients in the United States District Courts for the Northern and Southern Districts of Ohio and in appellate proceedings before the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit.

Federal civil-rights litigation presents procedural and substantive considerations that may differ from litigation in Ohio state courts. Our attorneys are experienced in federal motion practice, discovery, summary judgment, and appellate advocacy and understand the importance of developing a litigation strategy around the legal issues that may ultimately determine the case.

Dispositive Motions & Constitutional Litigation

Constitutional cases frequently present legal issues capable of resolution before trial.

Questions concerning the existence or scope of a constitutional right, qualified immunity, municipal liability, standing, causation, statutory requirements, and other threshold issues may provide grounds for dismissal or summary judgment depending upon the circumstances of the case.

We place particular emphasis on identifying potentially dispositive issues early and developing the record necessary to present those issues effectively.

When a case cannot be resolved through motion practice or an appropriate negotiated resolution, our attorneys are prepared to defend the matter through trial and appellate review.

Constitutional Appeals

Constitutional litigation often involves significant questions of law and issues subject to appellate review.

Williams & Finkbine's appellate attorneys have experience handling appeals involving constitutional rights, governmental immunity, statutory rights, and related federal and state-law issues.

Our appellate practice includes proceedings before Ohio's appellate courts, the Supreme Court of Ohio, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit.

Because appellate considerations can arise before a case reaches final judgment, our attorneys also evaluate preservation of error, standards of review, interlocutory appellate issues, and other matters that may affect subsequent appellate proceedings.

For over 25 years, the attorneys of Williams & Finkbine combine legal knowledge, professional acumen, hard work, and a commitment to our clients as a means of maximizing value and results at every stage of the litigation process.