Mediation & Arbitration

Our approach to Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) is informed by the experience in all aspects of litigation, supported by careful analysis, and focused on practical, real-world solutions.

 

Williams & Finkbine provides mediation, arbitration, and alternative dispute resolution services throughout Ohio. Our attorneys bring decades of civil litigation experience to the resolution of disputes outside the courtroom. 

We understand that successful alternative dispute resolution requires more than bringing parties together. It requires careful preparation, a realistic evaluation of the legal and factual issues, and an understanding of the practical considerations that drive each party’s position.

W&F’s alternative dispute resolution practice includes both representation of clients in mediation and arbitration and neutral services provided by experienced litigators.

Whether serving as advocates or neutrals, our attorneys approach alternative dispute resolution with a focus on preparation, practical analysis, and meaningful opportunities for resolution.

Mediation Services

Mediation provides parties with an opportunity to resolve a dispute through a confidential, facilitated negotiation rather than leaving the outcome entirely to a judge, jury, or arbitrator.

An effective mediator must understand more than the parties’ settlement positions. The mediator must be able to evaluate the legal and factual issues underlying the dispute, understand the risks facing each side, identify obstacles to resolution, and help the parties realistically evaluate their alternatives.

Williams & Finkbine provides private mediation services in civil disputes throughout Ohio.

Our mediation practice is informed by decades of experience litigating cases in Ohio’s state and federal courts, including matters involving insurance, personal injury, employment, construction, professional liability, governmental liability, commercial disputes, and other areas of civil litigation.

Richard A. Williams — Mediator & Arbitrator

Founding Partner Richard A. Williams provides private mediation and arbitration services to attorneys, parties, insurers, businesses, and other participants in civil disputes.

Richard brings decades of trial and litigation experience to the mediation process. His practice has included jury trials in state and federal courts throughout Ohio and litigation involving insurance, municipal liability, employment practices liability, construction disputes, professional liability, first-party insurance claims, and coverage matters.

That experience allows him to approach mediation from the perspective of someone who understands how cases are investigated, litigated, valued, negotiated, and tried.

As a mediator, Richard’s role is not to decide which party should prevail. It is to help the parties and their counsel identify the issues preventing resolution, realistically assess litigation risks, and determine whether an acceptable negotiated outcome can be reached.

His approach is resolution-oriented, practical, and grounded in the circumstances of the particular dispute.

Representation in Mediation

Williams & Finkbine represents clients participating in mediation.

Effective mediation advocacy begins well before the mediation session. Our attorneys evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the case, potential damages and exposure, applicable insurance considerations, prior settlement discussions, and the risks and costs associated with continued litigation.

We work with our clients to develop realistic objectives and a negotiation strategy appropriate to the matter.

For insurance clients, we understand the importance of providing claims professionals with the information necessary to evaluate exposure and obtain appropriate settlement authority before mediation.

Our objective is to enter mediation prepared to make informed decisions rather than using the mediation itself to begin evaluating the case.

Representation in Arbitration

Our attorneys represent clients in disputes subject to contractual, court-ordered, or agreed arbitration.

Although arbitration generally provides a different procedural framework from traditional litigation, effective advocacy still requires careful development of the factual record, legal analysis, witness preparation, documentary evidence, expert testimony when necessary, and persuasive presentation of the client’s position.

Williams & Finkbine represents clients in arbitration involving civil, commercial, construction, insurance-related, and other disputes within the firm’s areas of practice.

Why Consider Alternative Dispute Resolution?

Litigation is sometimes necessary, and some disputes require resolution by a judge, jury, or appellate court. In other matters, alternative dispute resolution can provide significant advantages.

Mediation can give parties greater control over the outcome, provide flexibility unavailable through a court judgment, reduce litigation expense, preserve confidentiality, and allow the parties to resolve a dispute without assuming the uncertainty of trial.

Arbitration can provide a private and potentially more streamlined forum for disputes that the parties have agreed to submit to a neutral decision-maker.

The appropriate method depends upon the dispute, the parties, the applicable agreements, and the objectives of those involved.

Our attorneys help clients evaluate those considerations and determine whether mediation, arbitration, continued negotiation, or litigation provides the most appropriate path toward resolution.

A Litigator’s Perspective on Dispute Resolution

The value of an experienced neutral is not simply familiarity with settlement negotiations. It is the ability to understand what happens if the case does not settle. W&F’s mediation and arbitration services are informed by extensive experience in civil litigation, dispositive motion practice, trial, and appellate proceedings.

That perspective allows our neutrals to understand the uncertainties that parties face as litigation progresses and to help participants realistically evaluate the alternatives to a negotiated resolution.

Our objective is not resolution at any cost. It is to provide a thoughtful process in which the parties can evaluate their positions, understand their risks, and determine whether a mutually acceptable resolution can be achieved.

Statewide Ohio Mediation & Arbitration

Williams & Finkbine provides mediation and arbitration services for civil disputes throughout Ohio.

With offices in Columbus, Cincinnati, and Cleveland and decades of statewide litigation experience, our attorneys are familiar with civil litigation practices and disputes arising throughout Ohio.

Mediations and arbitrations may be conducted in person or remotely when appropriate and agreed upon by the participants.

Schedule a Mediation or Arbitration

Williams & Finkbine Co., L.L.C. provides private mediation and arbitration services for civil disputes throughout Ohio. Attorneys may also contact the firm regarding representation of a client in mediation or arbitration.

To inquire about Richard A. Williams’ availability to serve as a mediator or arbitrator, obtain information regarding the mediation process, or discuss scheduling an alternative dispute resolution proceeding, contact Williams & Finkbine.

Coverage Areas

Civil Litigation Mediation

Williams & Finkbine's mediation services are particularly suited to civil litigation in which the parties benefit from a neutral who understands the litigation process and the considerations affecting case valuation.

Matters appropriate for mediation may include:

  • Personal injury and bodily injury claims;
  • Automobile and transportation liability;
  • Premises liability;
  • Insurance disputes;
  • First-party insurance claims;
  • Insurance coverage disputes;
  • Construction litigation;
  • Employment disputes;
  • Professional liability claims;
  • Municipal and governmental liability;
  • Commercial and contract disputes;
  • Property damage claims; and
  • Other civil litigation.

Every dispute presents different barriers to resolution. In some cases, the primary disagreement concerns liability. In others, the parties may disagree regarding causation, damages, insurance coverage, contractual obligations, litigation risk, or the value of the claim.

Effective mediation requires identifying those barriers and focusing the parties' attention on the issues that genuinely determine whether resolution is possible.

Insurance & Liability Mediation

Williams & Finkbine's extensive insurance defense experience provides a particularly strong foundation for mediation of insurance and liability disputes.

Insurance-related litigation often involves multiple considerations beyond the allegations contained in the pleadings. Liability, comparative fault, causation, medical evidence, damages, policy limits, coverage issues, litigation expenses, and the risks associated with trial may all influence settlement decisions.

A mediator familiar with the claims process can better understand the respective roles of the parties, counsel, claims professionals, and insurers participating in the negotiation.

W&F's experience representing insurance carriers and insureds provides practical insight into the evaluation and resolution of these matters.

Construction & Commercial Mediation

Construction and commercial disputes can involve complicated contractual relationships, extensive documentation, technical issues, multiple parties, and substantial litigation costs.

Mediation may provide an opportunity to resolve these disputes without the expense and uncertainty associated with continued litigation or arbitration.

Our experience in construction and commercial litigation allows us to understand disputes involving contract interpretation, payment, performance, delay, defective work, indemnification, insurance, and other issues that commonly arise between businesses and construction participants.

Employment & Professional Liability Mediation

Employment and professional liability disputes frequently present considerations extending beyond the monetary value of the claim.

Reputation, confidentiality, ongoing business or employment relationships, litigation expenses, and the uncertainty associated with a public trial can all affect the parties' evaluation of resolution.

Our attorneys' experience litigating employment and professional liability matters provides an understanding of the legal and practical considerations affecting these disputes and the challenges that may arise during settlement negotiations.

Arbitration Services

Arbitration provides parties with an alternative forum for resolving disputes outside traditional court proceedings.

Unlike mediation, in which the neutral facilitates negotiations but does not impose an outcome, an arbitrator is generally asked to hear the parties' evidence and arguments and render a decision in accordance with the governing arbitration agreement and applicable procedures.

Williams & Finkbine provides arbitration services in appropriate civil disputes.

Our litigation experience allows us to evaluate evidence, legal arguments, contractual provisions, damages, and other issues presented during arbitration while providing the parties with an organized and efficient process for resolving the dispute.

For over 25 years, the attorneys of Williams & Finkbine combine legal knowledge, professional acumen, hard work, and a commitment to our clients as a means of maximizing value and results at every stage of the litigation process.